Mother that Sparked a Boycott with a Facebook Post Says She Got It Wrong About Edward Teach Brewery
After a full year of boycotts that caused significant reputational damage to Edward Teach Brewery, Madonna Nash has come forward to admit she was wrong. Nash, the mother of musician Asia Norris, issued a public apology on Facebook, acknowledging that her post last year had unfairly escalated the controversy surrounding a public argument between brewery owner Gary Sholar and her daughter. The post sparked a widespread boycott of Edward Teach beers and ales across New Hanover County, dealing a blow to the brewery.
In her apology, Nash wrote, “This was a private matter that should have been kept private. I shouldn’t have involved myself in it, nor should I have allowed things to go as far as they did. The situation would have been better addressed immediately between the parties involved.” She added that Edward Teach Brewery had previously reached out to resolve the matter privately, which she now believes could have prevented the negative escalation in the community.
As part of her statement, Nash urged the public to stop boycotting Edward Teach Brewery, praising its reputation and encouraging patrons to return: “Please stop boycotting Edward Teach Brewery. There is no need to boycott them and no benefit from it.” She said she wanted to conclude this situation "on a high note" and announced plans to collaborate with the brewery for a charity event.
The brewery re-posted her apology on its Facebook page with a statement accepting Nash’s apology:
“We accept her apology and commend Madonna for acknowledging her mistakes and helping set the record straight. That takes courage. Stay tuned for details about the special event we’re working with Madonna to plan in our taproom next month!”
Nash’s full apology reads,
“I’d personally like to address and apologize for mistakes I made regarding my Edward Teach Brewery post last December. Over the past year, I have thoroughly gone through the events that took place at the brewery last November 16 with both sides, and I believe I made things sound worse than they were. I want to make it clear that no sexual assault, or anything like it, happened. I realize my post was read that way and I didn’t mean to suggest it. That’s on me. Again, I’d like to stress, and it has been confirmed, that nothing inappropriate of a sexual nature happened.
"Please also know, I wasn't there that night and I didn’t witness the events myself. In my post I relied on what my daughter told me and what her friend told me happened on November 16. But over the past year, I've come to learn that some details were omitted to me, not due to any action on Asia’s part. Asia's friend did not tell me then that she actually pushed the brewery's owner, before anything escalated that night. Nor did the friend tell me she had been the first to raise her voice and launch into the verbal dispute.
"In hindsight, I should not have trusted what Asia's friend told me, and I should not have posted anything. It wasn’t my place to post about something I was not a witness to. I let my instincts as a mother cloud my judgement and decision making. I didn’t consider the impact it might have or the harm it might cause, and unfortunately, every party involved ended up getting hurt in some way.
"This was a private matter that should have been kept private. I shouldn’t have involved myself in it, nor should I have allowed things to go as far as they did. The situation would have been better addressed immediately between the parties involved.
"After my post, Edward Teach did reach out and ask to speak with both Asia and myself, to try and resolve the conflict privately. I believe the events that followed wouldn’t have escalated the way they did if we would have responded then to resolve the issue. I do not believe anyone should have been prosecuted criminally for anything that happened that night or after. It is to be noted that the criminal charges were dismissed.
"And so, I apologize sincerely to Edward Teach Brewing, its owner Gary Sholar, and its employees for my actions. I take full responsibility for the mistakes I made, and I say it’s time to put this situation behind us. Let's end this on a high note.
"Please stop boycotting Edward Teach Brewery. There is no need to boycott them and no benefit from it. Edward Teach is still a great place to visit, enjoy, and perform. I know you miss the Teaches Peaches! Me too!! I hope to see such a great product back on shelves and in restaurants soon.
"Every cloud has a silver lining. I’m happy to announce that there will be some good coming from this as we work on moving forward. I will be collaborating with the brewery on a special event that we are currently in the process of planning, for which we will be raising money for an amazing local charity in support of our community. I can’t wait to tell you about it once we have finalized the details. So, stay tuned everyone!!!
"Madonna Nash"
Edward Teach Brewery: the Video, Legal Claims, and a Bomb Threat After November 2023 Incident
The incident, a verbal argument between Sholar and Norris, was the genesis for widespread backlash, including criminal charges, lawsuits, and a massive boycott of Edward Teach products across the Wilmington area. This boycott was damaging to the brewery and significantly impacted Sholar’s reputation.
Following the incident, Norris and her friend Paige Grant filed charges against Sholar for communicating threats, but the district attorney’s office later dismissed those charges.
Anonymous Video
A 10-second clip of the November exchange was anonymously published on Facebook on January 26, 2024. In the video, harsh words can be heard from Sholar as the musician walks away.
When StarNews inquired with Gary Sholar's attorney about the video, the reply was:
"...the anonymous poster appears to have either delayed starting filming, or they selectively edited the video to exclude all the moments leading up to the few seconds shown in what was posted under what appears to be a fake name. The video is part of an ongoing, malicious effort to defame ETB's owner, destroy the business, and throw its more than 20 employees out of work."
(Below) Video posted on Facebook shows a short segment of the November altercation between Edward Teach Bewery's owner and musician Asia Norris. Paige Grant can be seen stepping inbetween the two.
Legal Claims Against Flying Machine Manager Presents the Language Used in Nash's Facebook Post
Sholar also filed a legal claim against Eric Peterson, operations manager at Flying Machine Brewing Company, accusing him of defamation for amplifying Nash’s Facebook post and allegedly altering Edward Teach Brewery cans for sale at two supermarkets. This filed claim revealed Nash’s now-deleted post had accused Sholar of “grabbing,” “knocking over,” and “touch[ing]” Norris “without her consent” during the altercation and described Edward Teach Brewery as a “toxic and hostile work environment.”
Sholar and Peterson ultimately settled the matter out of court.
(Below) Edward Teach's lawsuit against Erik Peterson includes a list of statements from Nash's Facebook post that the brewery claimed to be false and defamatory. The filed claim can be viewed here.
(Below) WWAY News reports on a lawsuit against Erik Peterson, Operations Manager at Flying Machine Brewing Company, for placing labels on Edward Teach products at two Harris Teeter stores that spread false claims about the brewery and its owner, Gary Sholar. Lawsuit was later dropped by Sholar.
Bomb Threat Forced Temporary Closure of Edward Teach Brewery
In late January 2024, Edward Teach Brewery owner Gary Sholar reported a bomb threat to law enforcement. The threat came shortly after a 10-second Facebook video surfaced of the November incident. Out of concern for the safety of staff and patrons, Sholar temporarily closed the brewery while authorities investigated.
(Below) WWAY News reports on Edward Teach Brewery's temporary closure as a result of bomb threats.
Sholar's Guilty Pleas to Alcohol Violations
The negative publicity of the incident piqued North Carolina’s Alcohol Law Enforcement (ALE) agency to investigate the brewery, leading Sholar to plead guilty to two misdemeanors: failing to supervise a business with an Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) permit and allowing disorderly conduct on the premises. Sholar was fined $100 and was placed on six months of unsupervised probation.
Following the release of Nash's apology, it seems that Sholar's attorney, Thomas Varnum, informed WHQR's Ben Schachtman that while the defamation case against Madonna Nash has been dropped, allegations against her daughter, Asia Norris, and her friend, Paige Grant, are still pending.
(Below) WHQR's Ben Schachtman shared his insights on Facebook about the legal status of Asia Norris and Paige Grant in the ongoing Edward Teach Brewery controversy.
0 Comments