(Above) David Perry excuses himself from the New Hanover County Board of Education’s Sept. 1 meeting after his motion to discuss board compensation failed to receive a second.
Other NC school districts also tried raising their pay but were blocked; Hoke school board had to pay back their bonuses.
Voter apathy grows when colleagues shut out an elected official seeking straight answers about public money. David Perry questioned a reported 7.8% compensation increase for New Hanover school board members; weeks later, his colleagues censured him and removed his committee assignments.
Was the board enforcing conduct rules or pushing the pay issue out of view?
The board said it disciplined Perry for walking out in protest at the Sept. 1 meeting. It did not answer his question: Who authorized the New Hanover County School Board pay increase?
David Perry is a New Hanover County school board member who questions the board’s 7.8% compensation increase. He excused himself from the Sept. 9 board meeting after colleagues declined to add the pay raise issue to the agenda. The board later censured him and removed him from committee assignments.
(Below) David Perry excuses himself in protest from the meeting after stating the chair would not allow him to bring up the questionable raise for school board members.
(Below) David Perry provides explanation for his walkout during the Oct. 9 censure hearing.
Is the School Board Assuming Authority to Raise Their Own Pay?
On April 1, 2025, the school board adopted a nonbinding measure linking board members’ compensation to teacher pay increases. A memo sent the next day asking commissioners to include board member pay increases in the district’s annual budget beginning in 2026/27. The county commissioners have yet to agree to an automatic increase.
NHCS initially budgeted for a 3% teacher raise. In May, commissioners approved $111.4 million for the district and increased the per-pupil rate from $3,872 to $4,120 in the adopted county budget. The recommended budget said a $3.1 million increase in school operating support met NHCS’s expected 3% request. That higher dollar allocation did not mean commissioners had agreed to the school board’s teacher-linked compensation formula.
In June, before the General Assembly passed the final state budget, the school board approved a revised budget addressing teacher salaries. That timing suggests the board likely had advance notice of a larger state raise. The final state budget included a 7.8% teacher pay increase; both chambers passed it July 2, and the governor signed it July 7. But the county budget documents do not say commissioners agreed to the board’s 2025 measure linking members’ compensation to teacher raises.
Port City Daily reported that the 7.8% board raises were included in the budget commissioners approved. Perry publicly argued that the amount above 3% required a separate school-board amendment and commissioner approval. A source with direct knowledge of the board’s budget discussions told Cape Fear Beacon that the June revised budget for teacher raises had no explicit line item for board compensation. Cape Fear Beacon has not independently verified the source’s description of the revised budget.
The documents reviewed here do not show how the 7.8% amount appeared in the county-approved budget or whether commissioners approved the board’s compensation formula.
(Below) Watch the full October 9 censure hearing.
Was Censure Pretext for Icing Out an Elected Official Who Asked Uncomfortable Questions?
The telltales are present that the school board looked to have ostracize board member David Perry from his official duties, using his walkout as a pretext. The hearing’s sharpest tell was the uneven scope of debate. Chair Pete Wildeboer told Perry to limit his remarks to the Sept. 1 meeting events, while other members were allowed to cite a broader pattern of behavior and earlier disputes. That raises the question of whether the censure meeting became a vehicle to remove Perry from committees over disagreements that, on their own, did not warrant censure.
In an unusual move, the board bundled censure and committee removal into a single motion. Perry asked to separate the votes, but the request did not receive a second; the combined motion passed 6-1.
Committee removal does not bar Perry from speaking at board meetings, but it gives him fewer public opportunities to scrutinize decisions in committees.
Who Has the Authority to Set School Board Pay?
For as much as they may want a pay raise, school boards in North Carolina do not have the authority to set their own compensation. North Carolina law gives specific government bodies the authority to set school board member compensation: the State of North Carolina itself and the local county or city.
Under G.S. 115C-38, the school district’s local tax-levying authority, city or county, may set board compensation. Existing compensation stays in place until changed by this authority. The New Hanover County Board of Commissioners is the New Hanover County school district’s local tax-levying authority.
General Statute excerpt:
§ 115C‑38. Compensation of board members.
The tax‑levying authority for a local school administrative unit may, under the procedures of G.S. 153A‑92, fix the compensation and expense allowances paid members of the board of education of that local school administrative unit.
Funds for the per diem, subsistence, and mileage for all meetings of county and city boards of education shall be provided from the current expense fund budget of the particular county or city.
The compensation and expense allowances of members of boards of education shall continue at the same levels as paid on July 1, 1975, until changed by or pursuant to local act or pursuant to this section.
The 1979 Local Act is an example of how monthly base compensation, of $300 for the chair and $250 for other board members, is also set by the state. The act says:
§ 115C‑38. Compensation of board members.
The tax‑levying authority for a local school administrative unit may, under the procedures of G.S. 153A‑92, fix the compensation and expense allowances paid members of the board of education of that local school administrative unit.
Funds for the per diem, subsistence, and mileage for all meetings of county and city boards of education shall be provided from the current expense fund budget of the particular county or city.
The compensation and expense allowances of members of boards of education shall continue at the same levels as paid on July 1, 1975, until changed by or pursuant to local act or pursuant to this section.
North Carolina Precedent on School Boards Setting Their Own Compensation
North Carolina cases show how school-board pay disputes can turn on approval and the form of payment, though none decides New Hanover’s case:
- Union County: The school board approved a $200 monthly stipend increase, but members did not receive it after commissioners declined to act, the Charlotte Observer
- Lee County: Commissioners rejected a larger request and approved a 2.8% cost-of-living adjustment, The Rant
- Hoke County: The News-Journal reported school board members received $4,000 each in bonuses labeled “staff retention,” alongside payments to school employees. The district attorney found the board members’ payments unlawful but found no criminal intent; members repaid them.
Should a Board Member Be Able to Walk Out in Protest?
In a public Facebook post on Sept. 30, Perry described his departure as “peacefully leaving the meeting in protest.” He argued that Wildeboer had prevented him from explaining his compensation concerns, violating the board’s own ethics policy. Perry cited Policy 2120 C.3 on considering controversial issues fairly and without bias, and C.5 on encouraging board members’ free expression. In his account, the disciplinary hearing targeted his protest while overlooking the chair’s conduct.
(Below) On Sept. 30, David Perry posted a defense by citing school board policy.
Was Perry’s walkout protected speech after colleagues declined to discuss a potentially unlawful compensation increase?
Should he have stayed and pressed for answers, or was leaving in protest a reasonable response?
Barnhart’s “Week After Week” Lecture Comes With a July Asterisk
At about 17:43 in the Oct. 9 hearing, Josie Barnhart commented on Perry's walkout:
“...to continue to show up week after week after week for our kids is part of our job.” (Watch the hearing video.)
It takes some chutzpah to lecture colleagues about showing up week after week. Barnhart missed what may have been the most consequential vote of her term, the July 2024 vote to terminate Superintendent Charles Foust.
School board member David Perry is known to publicly address sacred cows for the sake of transparency. The board’s decision to censure him and remove his committee assignments after he questioned its compensation looks retaliatory. For officials who say they value transparency, sidelining a colleague for asking about public money is disingenuous.
In November, voters should decide what they expect from their elected officials. Can a school board use public funds without scrutiny? And when a member asks legitimate questions about that spending, should the response be to shut him out?
Both Josie Barnhart and Pat Bradford are up for re-election to the school board. Tim Merrick is challenging Dane Scalise for a state house seat. All three voted to censure Perry.
0 Comments