Is New Hanover County School Board Member Josie Barnhart Being Played, or is She Playing the Public?

by John McClane | Apr 10, 2025 | News Analysis, Commentary and Opinion

Did Barnhart Distort Facts and Mislead in Her Failed Attempt to Revive the AI Surveillance Pilot?

Did She Think No One Would Fact Check Her Letter?

Over the past few weeks, New Hanover County School Board (NHCS) Vice Chair Josie Barnhart has been relentless in her effort to push through Eviden’s AI surveillance pilot—even after it was voted down in March. She brought it up again at the April board meeting, but the board rejected it a second time in another 4 to 3 vote. She must be given credit for persistence.

The real issue isn’t just that Vice Chair Barnhart wanted to revisit the AI surveillance pilot,  it’s how she tried to make it happen. After the board voted to reject the controversial AI surveillance pilot project during the March 25th Agenda Meeting, Barnhart refused to drop the matter. In hours leading up to the April 1st Board Meeting, she launched her own campaign to reverse the decision, rallying around a letter she posted on Facebook urging ‘Board Members and Stakeholders’  to reconsider the North Carolina state grant that would pay $3.2 million to fulfill the project.

Barnhart’s message wasn’t as clear-cut as it seemed. While she claimed to have “new information” to justify bringing the proposal back for a vote, her letter contained misleading points and left out key details. Rather than making a genuine case, her push for reconsideration appeared to rely on dishonest tactics meant to manipulate members of the school board.

Most notably, Barnhart’s letter argued for using the grant money in ways that the statute does not explicitly allow. She claimed the board had the authority to reallocate $960K of the grant toward new cameras, despite the grant specifically stating that funds are designated for AI surveillance technologies that “integrate AI technology into existing cameras, video management systems, and alerting protocols.”

(Below) North Carolina's statutory language defining the parameters of the AI surveillance pilot grant Board Member Barnhart refers to.

2024 North Carolina Bill to allocate funds to AI in New Hanover and Davidson county schools

Barnhart’s push to revive the AI surveillance pilot appeared more focused on shaping public perception than presenting accurate information, raising questions about her intentions. Through her letter, she made no effort to address the specific concerns raised by board members who voted against the pilot. These concerns included vendor transparency, data privacy, cost sustainability, and Eviden’s ties to a foreign defense contractor. By ignoring these critical concerns, Barnhart reshaped the debate to fit her narrative, leaving the public to wonder whether she's being misled or trying to mislead the public.

Her Facebook letter was noticeably sloppy, even misstating one vendor’s name as "Raptor Communication" instead of the correct "Raptor Technologies." This one error prompted our editorial team to double-check the rest of her letter, something she probably didn’t expect anyone from the community to do.

(Below) New Hanover County Schools Vice Chair Josie Barnhart posted the following letter on Facebook, calling for the AI surveillance pilot program to be reconsidered. Click here or on image to read the letter.

Josie Barnhart's Facebook post with open letter

The following is what was discovered.

In 2023, a Republican-led School Board, including Barnhart, Already Voted to Purchase AI Surveillance Camera Systems

In 2023, all five Republican members of the New Hanover County School Board voted to approve the installation of Verkada-brand AI security cameras across four school campuses. These cameras, equipped with built-in facial recognition, were approved as a consensus item, making it unlikely that the board members knew they were voting for an AI-enabled facial recognition surveillance system.

The Agenda line-item summary

When school board members receive an agenda for an upcoming meeting, each item typically includes a brief summary for context. In the case of the Verkada system, for the April 2023 Board Meeting, the AI surveillance capabilities were downplayed in the agenda line-item summary. The person who composed the agenda item description (possibly NHCS’s Assistant Superintendent of Technology and Digital Learning, Dawn Brinson) noted the system simply as an “advanced solution” camera system, omitting any mention of AI facial recognition or other AI features. That summary also referenced the 2014 School Bond funding roll-out, stating that it “provided funding for security cameras at all of our facilities," which was part of a $9.5 million allocation. The bond’s funds were used for the camera system installation in 2023, making it one of the projects completed during the bond’s multi-year rollout.

(Below) The April 4, 2023 agenda entry, listed under “Consensus Items,” refers to Verkada’s AI-powered facial recognition system simply as an “advanced camera system.” It also notes that the 2014 Bond provided funding for security cameras across all NHCS facilities.

20230404 April Regular Meeting Agenda_ eBoardsolutions

This raises a question: If the 2014 Bond covered security cameras for all NHCS facilities, why does the district need to ask the county for additional funds to purchase more Verkada cameras? Where did the bond money go?

The Verkada camera system presented to the Board as an “advanced solution” without mentioning its AI-enabled facial recognition features. This lack of transparency denied the public, parents, and the school board the opportunity to discuss and deliberate the use of AI surveillance in New Hanover schools.

Why were Verkada’s AI capabilities hidden from the board and the public?

The AI Verkada systems voted on at this school board meeting were purchased for the following schools:

  • Williston Middle School
  • New Hanover High School
  • Gregory Elementary School 
  • Roland-Grise Middle School

The Verkada proposal and sales contract can be read here.

(Below) A spreadsheet summary from systems integrator Nitor, detailing the Verkada AI surveillance cameras purchased by NHCS in 2023. The proposal and sales agreement may be read here.

2023 Niko's total Verkada contract cost in spreadsheet

Barnhart: Because We Already Have AI Cameras, We Should Install More!

In her Facebook letter, Board Member Barnhart contends that since the district has already installed AI-enabled cameras, albeit without public or parental input, it only makes sense to expand the AI-surveillance footprint by adopting the Eviden system district-wide. This line of reasoning suggests that simply having some technology already in place justifies expanding it, without assessing whether it actually works or serves a clear purpose. If a senior IT or security executive used that logic to justify a $3.2 million purchase, it could very well end their career.

In her letter, Barnhart tries to strengthen her argument by comparing the Verkada and Eviden systems.

As Barnhart lays out company comparisons, she distorts the differences between Verkada and Eviden, selectively presenting facts that support her case while omitting key details that may undermine her argument. This completely misleads readers, including fellow board members who look to rely on accurate information.

For instance, Barnhart describes Verkada as a “global company with U.S. locations,” creating the impression that it’s foreign or less trustworthy. This statement misrepresents the fact that Verkada is an American-based company valued at $4 billion and backed by top U.S. venture capital firms like Sequoia Capital. Its global headquarters is in San Mateo, California. This information is easily found on Verkada’s website.

However, Barnhart omits facts that Eviden is not just based in France but is also intricately linked to the French military-industrial complex. Its parent company, Atos SE, is in financial turmoil, recently announcing a 10,000-to-1 reverse stock split to avoid being delisted from the Euronext Paris stock exchange. Atos or Eviden may not be in business 12, 24, or 36 months from now.

Barnhart's Product Solution Comparison

Barnhart attempts to compare the product capabilities of Verkada and Eviden, but her comparisons are misleading and incomplete. In her letter, she claims that Verkada’s AI-powered search capabilities require a paid subscription, framing it as a drawback. However, she fails to mention that the Eviden solution also requires a yearly licensing fee, ranging from $300,000 to $400,000 per year. This omission skews the comparison, giving the impression that only Verkada comes with ongoing costs.

Further, Barnhart addresses the data storage methods of each system, portraying Verkada’s cloud-based storage as a negative while praising Eviden for using “completely onsite local storage.” This statement is not just misleading; it’s outright false. Verkada employs a hybrid storage model: each camera has a solid-state drive or SD card that stores 30 days of video locally, while incident thumbnails are sent to the cloud for redundancy. This structure ensures both local and cloud-based data retention.

On the other hand, Eviden’s approach to data storage is entirely different. As stated by Eviden representative Shawn Hall during the town hall, the Eviden system itself does not record incidents; instead, it relies on the existing camera system at each school to record incidents. This means that how video recordings are stored would depend on the capabilities of the already-installed camera systems; which vary from school-to-school.

Additionally, the Raptor component of Eviden’s system solution, which manages alerting and incident management, stores Personally Identifiable Information (PII) in the cloud, as confirmed by Eviden representatives and Raptor’s own website.

Despite these facts, Barnhart misleads the public by claiming that Eviden’s “local server utilization” enhances data control and aligns with industry standards. This is a questionable claim, given that Eviden has stated they don't even store video of incidents.

(Below) During the NHCS town hall on the proposed AI surveillance pilot, Eviden representative Shawn Hall explains that their system does not store incident video.

(Below) During the NHCS town hall on the proposed AI surveillance pilot, Eviden representative Shawn Hall admits that the Raptor system does not store sensitive personal data of students on-site. 

(Below) Raptor Technologies web page states that their software is an off-site cloud-based solution.

Raptor is a cloud based solution web page.

SOC 2 compliance

In her letter, Josie Barnhart claims that the Eviden AI surveillance solution is SOC 2 compliant, presenting this as an advantage over the Verkada system. However, this claim is misleading for a few reasons.

What is SOC 2 compliance?

SOC 2 (Service Organization Control 2) certification is an important standard that shows a company has solid practices for managing data security and privacy. It comes in two types: Type 1, which is a one-time evaluation, and Type 2, which requires ongoing monitoring to ensure consistent protection. If Eviden truly had SOC 2 compliance, they would likely feature it prominently on their website, in press releases, or during presentations, especially since it’s a key certification when managing sensitive data. Yet, no such claim can be found on Eviden’s official site, in any of their press materials, or in the presentation given by Eviden representative Shawn Hall during the town hall meeting. This absence suggests that the Eviden system itself is not SOC 2 certified.

The only part of the Eviden solution found to have any SOC 2 certification is the Raptor Technologies component, which currently holds a SOC 2 Type 1 certification. However, this is not as robust as Type 2, which requires ongoing evaluation rather than just a one-time assessment. Plus, Raptor’s certification applies only to its own products, not the entire Eviden system. Barnhart appears to suggest that the entire Eviden AI surveillance solution is SOC 2 certified, but her wording is so vague it's unclear what exactly she's claiming. If she has documentation showing that Eviden itself holds a SOC 2 certification, she should make that public. Otherwise, implying that Raptor’s certification extends to the full system is misleading.

In contrast, Verkada has completed a SOC 2 Type 2 audit, which is more comprehensive and demonstrates a long-term commitment to data security. Verkada makes this clear by allowing potential customers to download their SOC 2 report directly from their website. This is something Eviden doesn’t do if they are truly compliant. Raptor does mention its SOC 2 Type 1 certification on its website, and that the company is in the process of a Type 2 examination.

Again, Barnhart just doesn’t say in the letter if she is referencing Eviden or Raptor when she mentions SOC 2 compliance. It’s ambiguous.

Bottom line, by emphasizing unverified claims about Eviden’s SOC 2 compliance while ignoring Verkada’s verified SOC 2 Type 2 certification, Barnhart presents a skewed comparison that misrepresents the reality of each brand’s security standards. Her vague assertion about Eviden’s certification, without clarifying the type or offering any verifiable evidence, raises serious concerns about her understanding of the issue.

What is Raptor’s Emergency Management System?

The Raptor Emergency Management System is a software suite designed to help schools manage safety protocols, including emergency response, communication, and reunification during crises. It offers features like visitor management, drill management, and real-time alerts, but it does not include AI surveillance or threat detection capabilities. Despite being promoted as part of the Eviden AI surveillance proposal, Raptor falls outside the eight requirements listed in the NC statute needed to receive the grant. This product should’ve been considered outside the scope of the AI pilot.

(Below) A Raptor Technologies video explaining the service their product provides.

Finally, in another comparison between Verkada and Eviden, Barnhart once again omits key details. She highlights Raptor Technologies' significant market share in U.S. schools. However, she fails to mention that Raptor’s role in the Eviden system is limited to alert and reunification services, which do not meet the definition of AI surveillance as required by the state grant.

A quick call to Verkada confirmed that the company’s systems are in about 30% of all U.S. school districts. In contrast, Eviden has no presence in K-12 education within the United States — not a single school. This key difference should have been a major point of consideration when spending taxpayers’ money, however, Barnhart failed to either do her own due diligence, or present her due diligence, to the public.

It’s becoming more obvious: either Josie Barnhart doesn’t fully understand the advanced technology she’s advocating the district spend millions on, or there’s something else going on that the public hasn’t been told.

Had she attended the town hall and heard directly from the vendor, she might have walked away with a better grasp of what the Eviden system actually does, and what it doesn’t.

By omitting information she clearly doesn’t want the public to understand, Barnhart has compromised her credibility as a board member. Moving forward, it’s difficult to see how the public and other board members can fully trust her statements.

Lingering Questions About Influence and Motives

Deeper questions remain: Why did Barnhart push so hard for the AI surveillance pilot despite significant red flags? Was she acting entirely on her own, or did local political figures encourage her to keep the issue alive? And given the inconsistencies and misleading points in her letter, did she even write it herself, or did someone else help craft the message?

Another unresolved issue concerns the $9.5 million from the 2014 Bond that the April 2023 Agenda note said covered cameras at all NHCS facilities. If that funding was already allocated for security upgrades, why is the district now asking the county for additional money to purchase more cameras? The board and the public deserve clear answers on how that money was spent and why more funds are now needed.

Without hesitation, GOP leaders threw their support behind Josie Barnhart’s letter, even though it promotes a no-bid deal with a financially unstable foreign defense contractor. And, the company has no proven experience in U.S. K-12 schools. So, why did they back Josie's plan with so many red flags and unanswered questions? And why hasn't anyone backed an American company from the get-go?

Stay caught up. Visit the News Roundup on our homepage for the latest headlines, updated twice daily.

Submit a Correction

Name(Required)

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Sign up for our Newsletter

Stay curious. Stay connected. Sign up for news that brings your world into focus

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Support Local Independent News and Analysis!

Amid widespread left-leaning media bias, our role is pivotal. Your sponsorship supports local and regional story coverage, aiding our expansion.