NHCS Board Chose Participation in Pettiness over Solutions for Adequate Compensation for Educators
On Friday, thousands of North Carolina educators are expected to gather in Raleigh for the “Kids Over Corporations” rally, a statewide protest over public school funding, teacher pay, and the long-running strain inside classrooms. In Wilmington, New Hanover County Schools will remain open, even as some educators plan to attend the Raleigh event or a local demonstration at Long Leaf Park.
The timing lands hard in New Hanover County.
For months, NHCS board member David Perry pushed for a board-led Employee Benefits and Retention Committee. The idea was not complicated. If teachers are leaving, and if pay and affordability are part of the problem, elected board members should publicly examine ways to increase earning potential, including bonuses or extra compensation for strong performance.
Instead, the Republican-led board delayed the effort, changed its structure, moved it under Human Resources, and later punished Perry after a nasty blowup with board member Pat Bradford. The fight became personal. Underneath the wreckage sits a larger question for Wilmington families: Is the NHCS board serious about making teacher pay competitive, or is it more interested in controlling who gets to ask the question?
David Perry’s Teacher Retention Pitch Began on the 2024 Campaign Trail
Perry’s interest in teacher pay did not appear out of nowhere. During his 2024 campaign for the New Hanover County Board of Education, he argued the district needed to focus spending on core school functions. In a Port City Daily candidate questionnaire, Perry said NHCS should cut “nice to haves,” “pet projects,” and waste, then redirect money toward priorities such as “hiring and retaining more good teachers.”
That campaign pledge later took shape as the Employee Benefits and Retention Committee.
The committee was supposed to explore ways to recruit and keep high-quality employees in a county where housing, groceries, gas, and insurance have become harder to afford on a teacher’s paycheck. Perry wanted a standing board committee, not a quiet internal staff process. A standing committee would have given board members a more formal role, regular meetings, and public accountability.
That distinction became the fault line.
David Perry is a New Hanover County Board of Education member. Perry campaigned on fiscal restraint, curriculum transparency, and improving systems to hire and retain top teachers. His tenure has included high-profile disputes over committee authority, teacher compensation, and board governance.
Melissa Mason’s Committee Process Sparked Early Tension
The board’s committee fights started well before the April blowup. January 2025, Port City Daily reported on controversy over Chair Melissa Mason’s committee assignments. A Jan. 8 list showed Perry as head of the policy committee, but Perry later said Mason had demoted him to member, with former chair Pete Wildeboer becoming the head instead.
Mason defended her process, saying committee assignments were still in draft form and that she wanted every board member to serve somewhere aligned with both interest and growth. Other board members said the process was imperfect but fair. Perry’s objection was narrower. He said he did not understand the initial list could change after it was shared.
The episode set the tone. Perry believed fellow Republicans were yanking him around on committee power. Both sides said they wanted to focus on schools. But record shows the Republican-led board spent a great deal of energy fighting over who would be allowed on what committee.
In March 2025, a teacher performance ad hoc committee was formed, but never met. But in July, it was disbanded. Then, in November, the Board attempted to restart it, but didn't garner enough votes.
NHCS Committee Fight Shifted From Board Oversight to HR Advice
On Feb. 10, 2026, the board approved Perry’s Employee Benefits and Retention Committee. It passed unanimously, 7-0, but with a catch. The board delayed the committee’s work until after the district budget was adopted. Perry said the committee was designed to recommend recruitment and retention strategies, including options beyond immediate pay increases. No funding commitment was authorized.
Then came the larger change.
At the March 18 policy committee meeting, committee leaders Mason, Bradford, and Merrick were expected to formerly add the new committee the list of committees. Instead, they debated whether the committee should be a standing body, an ad hoc group, or an advisory committee. The policy committee voted to move the Employee Benefits and Retention Committee to advisory status under HR, then forward the revised policy to the full board.
Jennifer Geller is NHCS’s assistant superintendent of human resources and top HR official. The board moved the Employee Benefits and Retention Committee under HR. That makes Geller the most likely central office leader to oversee the teacher compensation and retention effort, though NHCS has not publicly named a chair.
That move watered down Perry’s idea. HR should obviously be involved in any teacher pay conversation. The department understands salaries, benefits, job classifications, recruitment, and vacancies. Finance would also need a seat at the table.
But staff support is not the same as board oversight.
If central office staff had already solved the teacher retention and affordability problem, Perry’s committee would have been unnecessary. NHCS has had years to study pay, turnover, staffing shortages, and morale. Moving the work under HR kept the effort inside the same administrative structure already responsible for bringing options forward.
A board-led committee would have done something different. It could have forced a public conversation about spending priorities, local supplements, bonuses, advanced teaching roles, and whether district dollars are aligned with the stated goal of keeping strong teachers.
Teacher Turnover Data Gave the NHCS Board a Clear Warning
NHCS does not have to guess whether teacher retention is a real problem.
WHQR reported that New Hanover’s teacher attrition rate was 11.8% in 2022-23 after historically hovering around 9%. For 2023-24, the rate decreased and aligned with the state rate of about 10%, but the district still had a 10% vacancy rate, with particular need for K-5 classroom teachers and high school career and technical education teachers.
North Carolina’s statewide numbers are also bleak. The Department of Public Instruction reported a 10.11% teacher attrition rate for 2024-25, slightly up from 9.88% the prior year. State Superintendent Maurice “Mo” Green said public schools cannot become the best in the nation unless teachers are “adequately compensated, trained and revered.”
Pay is not the only reason teachers leave. Some retire. Some move. Some leave for health or family reasons. But compensation sits at the center of the statewide debate. According to EdNC, the National Education Association ranked North Carolina 43rd in average teacher salary last school year and projected the state would fall to 46th this school year.
That is the backdrop for Friday’s rally. It is also the backdrop for the NHCS committee fight.
Pat Bradford, the Logrolling, and the Blowup
By April 1, Perry was trying to save his preferred version of the committee. WHQR reported Bradford said Perry, who had appeared to be on the fence about LifeWise Academy, texted her asking for support to keep the Employee Benefits and Retention Committee as a standing committee in exchange for his vote in favor of the program. LifeWise Academy is a Bible-based program seeking to take students off campus during the school day. After the public blowup, it is unclear how Perry would vote on LifeWise now.
Bradford called it a “quid pro quo.” Perry later defended it as normal political deal-making, but the text turned the committee dispute into an ethics fight.
Pat Bradford is a Republican member of the New Hanover County Board of Education and is up for re-election this November. Her tenure includes a clear record of backing board action against speech she opposes. That includes the recent move to discipline David Perry.
What is "Political Logrolling"?
Political logrolling is vote-for-vote bargaining between elected officials. In ordinary public policy work, it can be both legal and ethical: one member supports another member’s proposal because that support helps move a separate public priority forward.
In Perry’s case, the conduct Bradford labeled a “quid pro quo” more closely resembles logrolling because the alleged exchange involved two public policy votes, not a private benefit. The line is crossed when an exchange involves personal gain, money, gifts, jobs, contracts, campaign benefits, threats, private favors, or any benefit detached from the public interest.
Allegations that an official steered campaign funds or public-facing political resources toward a personal organization, like a church, would raise a different and more serious ethical question. It could also become a legal question if evidence showed the action benefited the official personally, rather than serving a legitimate public or campaign purpose.
A policy trade may look unseemly to voters, especially on a school board, but it is not automatically corruption simply because one official asks another to support a different public issue.
NHCS policy does not appear to specifically prohibit political logrolling or policy bargaining. Policy 2120 could still be used to criticize a vote trade if board members believed it showed bias, surrendered independent judgment, served partisan or personal gain, or blocked fair public consideration of an issue.
But that argument is weaker in Perry’s case. No one alleged that a third party pressured him, offered him money, promised him a personal benefit, or tried to buy his vote. His proposed exchange involved two public policy matters before the board. If Perry was still undecided on LifeWise Academy, the exchange also gave Bradford an opening to make her case for the program. Neither Bradford nor Perry claimed there was personal or partisan gain. Bradford called it a “quid pro quo,” but based on the public facts, it more closely resembles ordinary political logrolling.
We found no Southeastern North Carolina school district having a policy that specifically declares logrolling unethical or prohibits it under another label. The ethical concern in school board policy is not ordinary policy bargaining. It is personal gain, private benefit, financial interest, contracts, coercion, conflicts of interest, or surrendering judgment to outside partisan or special-interest pressure.
An Escalating Feud
The board-member feud escalated after Perry criticized Bradford and other Republican board members online. Port City Daily reported Perry called Bradford a “vindictive b!tch” and later compared Wildeboer, Bradford, Josie Barnhart, and Mason to “Pharisees of old.” Perry later apologized for using profanity but said he stood by the essence of his criticism.
At an April 28 meeting, Wildeboer acknowledged he had erred by trying to impose discipline through a letter without a full board vote. The board then voted 5-2 to uphold the punishment and remove Perry from committee assignments. Perry and Democrat Tim Merrick voted no.
Perry argued serving on committees is part of a board member’s job, not a perk. He said removing him told voters the board’s judgment mattered more than their votes.
(Below) Pat Bradford’s April 26 addendum asked the NHCS board to consider revoking David Perry’s committee assignments and other board privileges for at least four months. The letter cited Perry’s social media posts, public comments, and vote-trading text, even while acknowledging the LifeWise exchange was “not illegal.” (click image to enlarge.)
(Below) New Hanover County Board of Education member David Perry defends his First Amendment rights before the board votes 5-2 to punish him by removing him from committee assignments. The dispute followed Perry’s criticism of Republican colleagues and the fight over his Employee Benefits and Retention Committee.
"Vindictive" Bradford Gets Revenge, Committee Punishment Leaves NHCS with Less Public Oversight
The board’s formal reason for punishing Perry was his conduct. Bradford’s April 26 addendum request sharpened that case. In the two-page letter, she asked the board to consider revoking Perry’s board privileges, including committee assignments, for at least four months. Her examples focused almost entirely on Perry’s speech: social media posts, remarks about other board members, criticism of the 100 Black Men organization, comments related to a proposed all-boys charter school, and the text exchange over the Employee Benefits and Retention Committee.
The letter framed those actions as policy and ethics violations. It also acknowledged the LifeWise vote-trade allegation was “not illegal,” but said it violated board policy and showed poor judgment. That distinction is important. Bradford was not asking the board to punish Perry for theft, fraud, bribery, or misuse of public money. She was asking the board to punish him for political speech, religiously framed criticism, harsh personal comments, and a vote-trading text she conceded was not illegal.
Perry’s speech could be ugly. It could be unwise. Some of it plainly made governing harder. But elected officials do not lose First Amendment protection because their speech is abrasive, personal, or inconvenient to colleagues. A censure would have let the board answer Perry’s speech with its own speech. Removing him from committees went further. It limited his ability to perform part of the job voters elected him to do.
Still, the punishment did not unfold in a vacuum. The conduct fight grew out of the same dispute that had been building for months: Perry’s teacher retention committee.
Perry’s core complaint was that Republican colleagues changed his committee into an advisory body without fully hearing him out. He wanted a public, board-driven structure to examine pay and retention. They moved the work under HR, where it would likely sink back into Central Office habits that have not produced enough help for educators.
If HR or district administration already had a strong solution for teacher pay and retention, they had years to bring it forward.
A district with a 10% vacancy rate and years of attrition does not need less scrutiny. It needs more. Board members should be asking whether NHCS can trim fat and redirect local dollars toward teacher salaries. They should also ask whether high-performing teachers have real paths to higher pay, and whether central office recommendations are bold enough for the size of the problem.
Republican board members can say they support teachers, but teachers have heard plenty of that before. With the exception of Perry, the more tenured Republicans on this board have had years to tackle teacher pay, affordability, and retention. They are not new to the problem. They are part of the record now. Teachers looking for help on pay and retention should not count on them.
0 Comments